The High Court, on Tuesday,
delivered judgment in a significant case on pension security on which ITC
Consulting advised.
In the case, a bank, owed
money by two individuals, initially succeeded in appointing a receiver over the
individuals’ pension assets in March this year.
The appointment was appealed to the Commercial Division of the High
Court and the very welcome news for many pension holders is that the Court
struck out the appointment of the receiver on Tuesday.
The Court considered that
the characteristics of the pension schemes precluded the appointment of a
receiver. The schemes concerned were individual self-administered schemes and
ITC Consulting was appointed by solicitors for some beneficiaries of the
pension schemes to give an expert opinion.
The prevailing view in the
pensions industry was that pre-retirement benefits were not vulnerable to
attack by creditors. However, there was
no clear Irish legal authority on the point so the matter was not absolutely
free from doubt until the judgment. The 2010 case where a receiver was
appointed over Brendan Murtagh’s Approved Retirement Fund had also caused
concern. The issue has received
significant attention from the media and commentators as for many people their
pension is their most valuable asset and the idea that somehow creditors could
access someone’s pension was an understandable worry. Thankfully, the judgment has now clarified
matters in favour of the pension holders.
It is important to note
that, whilst most Irish pension schemes have the same characteristics as the
pension schemes in the case, all scheme documents must be reviewed to ensure
that appropriate protections are in place. This is a service that ITC
Consulting is well placed to provide in view of its experience in this
area.
Associate Director
ITC Consulting